Syllabus: GS–I & V: Modern Indian History

Why in the news?

Renewed academic and public discussions around India’s freedom struggle have once again brought focus to the ideological contrasts and mutual respect between Mahatma Gandhi and Subhas Chandra Bose, two towering leaders who shaped India’s independence in very different ways.

Introduction: One goal, different routes

• The relationship between Gandhiji and Netaji represents one of the most complex yet inspiring dynamics of India’s freedom movement.
• Despite a 28-year age gap and sharply different ideologies, both were united by an unshakeable commitment to India’s independence.
• Their association, from 1921 to 1945, was marked by debate, disagreement, confrontation, and deep mutual respect.

The first meeting and early influence

• In 1921, a young Subhas Chandra Bose met Gandhiji in Bombay after resigning from the Indian Civil Service, a powerful symbolic act of sacrifice.
• Gandhiji recognised Bose’s potential and advised him to work under Chittaranjan Das in Bengal.
• Though Netaji felt Gandhiji lacked a concrete revolutionary plan, he deeply admired Gandhiji’s mass appeal and moral authority.
• Netaji later became the first to publicly call Gandhiji the “Father of the Nation” in a 1944 radio broadcast.

Ideological divergence: Means versus ends

• Gandhiji’s philosophy
  • Absolute faith in nonviolence, truth, and mass civil disobedience.
  • Belief that means are as important as ends.
  • Vision of a decentralised, village-based economy, symbolised by the charkha.
• Netaji’s philosophy
  • Belief in armed struggle and direct confrontation with colonial power.
  • Advocacy of complete independence (Poorna Swaraj) much earlier than the Congress mainstream.
  • Support for rapid industrialisation and a strong centralised state inspired by socialist ideas.

Major conflicts and political break

• The Non-Cooperation Movement withdrawal (1922) after the Chauri Chaura incident deeply disappointed Netaji, who saw it as a lost opportunity.
• The sharpest conflict emerged in 1939, when Netaji defeated Gandhiji’s nominee in the Congress presidential election.
• Gandhiji publicly acknowledged this as a personal defeat.
• The Tripuri Congress Session exposed irreconcilable differences, leading to Netaji’s resignation and the formation of the Forward Bloc.

World War II and the Indian National Army

• Netaji’s escape from house arrest in 1941 and formation of the Indian National Army marked a decisive departure from Gandhian methods.
• His alliance with Axis powers during World War II was strongly criticised by Gandhiji, yet his patriotism was never doubted.
• Gandhiji famously described Netaji as the “Patriot of Patriots”, acknowledging his courage and sacrifice even while rejecting his strategy.

Mutual respect beyond disagreement

• In July 1944, Netaji sought Gandhiji’s blessings through a radio message, praising the Quit India Movement.
• After the war, Gandhiji personally supported Indian National Army soldiers, recognising their sacrifices as part of the national struggle.
• Both leaders understood that India needed multiple streams of resistance to weaken colonial rule.

Key concepts explained (for exams)

• Ahimsa: Gandhiji’s principle of nonviolence as a moral and political tool.
• Poorna Swaraj: Complete independence, demanded forcefully by Netaji.
• Forward Bloc: A political group formed by Netaji after leaving the Congress.
• Indian National Army: An armed force led by Netaji to fight British rule.
• Mass mobilisation: Gandhiji’s strategy of involving ordinary Indians in politics.

Conclusion: Unity in diversity

• Gandhiji and Netaji symbolise the plurality of thought within India’s freedom movement.
• They disagreed on methods, not on the destination.
• Their relationship teaches that national movements can accommodate ideological diversity without losing unity.
• India’s independence was not the result of one path, but of multiple complementary struggles converging towards a single dream.

Exam Hook – 

Mains Question:
“The relationship between Mahatma Gandhi and Subhas Chandra Bose highlights the coexistence of ideological diversity and national unity in India’s freedom struggle.” Discuss.

Core takeaway:
India’s freedom was achieved not through uniform thinking, but through the creative tension between moral resistance and revolutionary action, embodied by Gandhiji and Netaji.

SOURCE