Syllabus: GS-II: Effects of Politics of Countries on India’s Interests

Why in the News

The Trump administration has announced a sharp increase in the fee for H-1B visa applications to $100,000 annually per new application. The move is aimed at curbing wage arbitrage in the U.S. IT sector, reducing dependence on foreign workers, and protecting American jobs. This comes at a time when Indian IT companies such as TCS, Infosys, and Wipro are among the largest beneficiaries of the H-1B visa system, with Indian nationals constituting over 65% of all H-1B workers in the U.S.

What is the H-1B Visa Programme?

• The H-1B is a non-immigrant visa that allows U.S. companies to employ foreign workers in “specialty occupations” requiring technical or professional expertise, such as IT, finance, engineering, and medicine.
• It was created under the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1990.
• Annual cap: 85,000 new H-1B visas (65,000 regular cap + 20,000 for advanced degree holders from U.S. institutions).
• Employers must pay the prevailing wage set by the U.S. Department of Labor to ensure foreign hires do not undercut American workers.
  

How H1-B Benefited Indians?

• Dominance of Indians: Around 70% of all H-1B visas go to Indian nationals, particularly from the IT services sector.
• Gateway to U.S. jobs: Provides Indian professionals, especially engineers and IT workers, access to high-paying jobs.
• Remittances: H-1B visa holders contribute significantly to India’s remittance economy.
• Global exposure: Enhances Indian talent’s integration into global tech ecosystems.
  

Issues Related to H-1B Visa

• Allegations of misuse: Critics argue firms use it for cheap labour, replacing U.S. workers.
• Lottery system flaws: Companies flood applications to increase chances, creating unfair advantages.
• Dependency on U.S. policy shifts: India’s IT sector becomes vulnerable to sudden visa restrictions.
• Job security concerns: Visa holders’ status is tied to employers, making them vulnerable to exploitation.
  

Criticisms of H-1B Visa

• Wage suppression: American workers claim H-1B employees are hired at lower wages.
• Mass layoffs & hiring contradiction: Companies like Meta and Google filed thousands of H-1B applications even while laying off U.S. staff.
• Brain drain from other nations: Critics argue the U.S. system exploits global talent pools while restricting pathways to citizenship.
  

Why is the Fee Hike a Concern for India?

• Economic burden: At $100,000 per application, Indian IT firms face massive cost escalation.
• Erosion of business model: Indian IT services thrive on labour arbitrage; higher visa fees make this model unsustainable.
  
• Reduced competitiveness: U.S. rivals and Big Tech firms may absorb costs more easily than Indian outsourcing companies.
• Impact on students: Indian students in U.S. universities may see dimmed prospects for post-graduate employment.
  

Implications of H-1B Restrictions on Global Mobility

• Talent diversion: Countries like Canada, UK, and Australia may benefit by attracting skilled Indian talent.
• Innovation loss for U.S.: America risks losing its edge in STEM fields if global talent shifts elsewhere.
• Shift to offshoring: Instead of hiring Indians onshore in the U.S., companies may move entire operations overseas, hurting U.S. workers.
• Concentration of talent: Larger companies (Google, Microsoft) may absorb costs, sidelining smaller startups and innovators.
  

Could L-1 Visa Be an Alternative?

• About L-1 Visa: For intra-company transfers; allows executives, managers (L-1A), and specialised knowledge employees (L-1B) to move from foreign branches to U.S. offices.
• Advantages:
  No cap or lottery system.
  • Dual intent allows green card applications.
  • Spouses (L-2) automatically get work permits.
• Limitations:
  • Employees must have worked for the company abroad for at least 1 year.
  • Hard limits on stay (5 years L-1B, 7 years L-1A).
  • No portability between employers.
• Conclusion: L-1 is a useful tool for large Indian IT firms but not a universal substitute for H-1B, especially for fresh graduates or startups.
  

Way Forward

• Diversification of markets: Indian IT firms should reduce reliance on U.S. visas by strengthening delivery models in Europe, Asia-Pacific, and Africa.
• Offshore expansion: Building global delivery centres in India to retain jobs locally.
• Policy dialogue: India must engage with the U.S. through forums like the Trade Policy Forum to safeguard Indian workers’ interests.
• Skill upgradation: Indian workforce should be trained in AI, cloud, and cybersecurity to remain globally competitive.
• Explore alternatives: Greater use of L-1 visas, remote working models, and partnerships with U.S. firms.
  

Conclusion

The $100,000 H-1B visa fee hike marks a turning point in U.S. immigration policy and a significant challenge for India’s IT sector. While it aims to protect American workers, it risks undermining the U.S.’s own innovation ecosystem by driving global talent to competitor nations. For India, this is both a threat and an opportunity—an urgent call to diversify its IT industry models, strengthen domestic job creation, and negotiate strategically with the U.S.

Mains Question

1. The U.S. administration’s recent hike in H-1B visa fees has major implications for India’s IT industry and global talent mobility. Discuss the challenges it poses for India and suggest measures to safeguard Indian interests. (250 words)

Article link